In a hurry? Our top pick for the best quesadilla maker is the Hamilton Beach Pizza and Quesadilla Maker. It’s affordable, has great customer reviews, does more than make quesadillas, and workes great every time.
You don’t have to save quesadillas for a night out at a Mexican restaurant. You can have fresh, delicious, and nutritious quesadillas at home!
Quesadillas are a great meal to make at home because it’s whatever you make of it. The outside is just a toasted tortilla, so it’s as delicious as you want to make it.
Want to make healthy, super clean quesadillas? You can do that!
Want to make protein quesadillas? Yes, load it up with grilled chicken and cheese.
Want to make dessert quesadillas? Go ahead and make some Nutella quesadillas. The possibilities are endless.
In this article, we at Kitchen Appliance Lab will go over some of our favorite quesadilla makers and then recommend our top choice.
Here are the quesadilla makers we reviewed:
- Elite Gourmet Quesadilla Maker
- Brentwood Quesadilla Maker
- Betty Crocker Quesadilla Maker
- Black and Decker Quesadilla Maker
- Hamilton Beach Pizza and Quesadilla Maker – Top Pick!
- Sante Fe Quesadilla Maker
- El Paso Quesadilla Maker
Elite Gourmet Quesadilla Maker
Don’t ever settle for little quesadillas again! This Elite Gourmet will make big 11 inch quesadillas!
This is more than a snack, especially if you load them up with toppings.
- Locking latch – to keep your quesadillas and filling from flowing out
- Automatic slicing – the top has ridges which automatically slice your quesadilla into 6 wedges
- Indicator lights – lets you know when the quesadilla maker is on and then when it’s ready to cook
- Drain and drip tray – ensures that any grease that escapes won’t fall on your countertops
- Easy to store – since it locks, it’s easy to store vertically pretty much anywhere
- Easy to clean – the drip tray, drainage system, and nonstick plates ensure that you’ll always have an easy time cleaning it up
The nonstick cooking plate on this 11 inch quesadilla maker along with the drain grooves and drip tray make it a winner.
It’s super easy to clean and very easy to use. Because it’s compact, it’s also easy to store.
Beware though, the latch does get hot enough that it gets uncomfortablet open or close.
All in all, this is a great quesadilla maker and one that you can’t go wrong with.
Brentwood Quesadilla Maker
Looking for snack quesadillas instead of meal ones? Well, this Brentwood Quesadilla maker may be the one for you.
What do I mean by that? While most quesadalla makers make 10 or 11 inch quesadillas, this one is limited to 8 inches.
That’s not necessarily a bad thing, unless you usually don’t eat that much or know that you won’t want bigger quesadillas.
- Makes an 8 inch quesadilla
- Nonstick cooking plates
- Easy to clean
- Removable drip tray
- Indicator lights
This Brentwood Quesadilla Maker is a solid appliance that will do exactly what it should be doing – making quesadillas.
There’s nothing fancy or truly unique about it. It has nonstick plates, indicator lights, and a drip tray, which is all pretty standard.
It does have 900 watts of power, which means that it cooks up quesadillas pretty fast.
Again, similar to the Elite Gourmet one, this unit gets hot enough to be uncomfortable to the touch.
Still, it’s a solid appliance that does it’s job and is affordable. Yes, there are better quesadilla makers out there, but you can buy this one and be satisfied with your purchase.
Betty Crocker Pizza Maker
If you’re looking for something special, something truly unique, then this may be it.
This Betty Crocker Pizza and Quesadilla Maker is a top of the line kitchen appliance that is multi-functional, affordable, and easy to use.
This makes a 12 inch quesadilla (or pizza!), along with many other dishes. From cinammon rolls, cookie cakes, omelets, to nachos, this will be your new go-to kitchen appliance.
- Variable temperature control setting – cooking temperature ranges rom 70 to 400 degrees
- Indicator lights – features two indicator lights, one for power on and one for ready to cook
- Energy efficient – bakes at the most efficiently needed temperature
- Nonstick coated plates – special nonstick coating allows you to bake to perfection while keeping things easy to cleanup
- Bonus – includes a small pizza cutter and recipe book
This is a great appliance that allows you to do many different things with it. It’s durable, easy to use, and easy to clean. You can’t really go wrong with this appliance.
Black & Decker Quesadilla Maker
Yes, you probably know Black & Decker the brand because you see them at Home Depot, right? Maybe you have a power drill by them or some other power tool.
Well, they also make kitchen appliances. And their kitchen appliances are actually pretty good!
This quesadilla maker is one of them!
- 8 inch nonstick plates
- Nonstick coating
- Removable drip tray
This quesadilla maker is on the smaller side at just 8 inches. Still, it’s a durable appliance that does exactly what it’s supposed to do – make good tasting quesadillas!
And because it has 900 watts of power, your quesadillas will be done in just around 4 minutes or so!
Hamilton Beach Pizza and Quesadilla Maker
This Hamilton Beach Pizza and Quesadilla Maker is our go to kitchen appliance. This is a high quality multi-functional kitchen appliance that does way more than just make quesadillas and pizzas.
This is basically an enclosed, flat, heating element. That means that your possibilities are endless!
- Cooks a 12 inch quesadilla or pizza
- Rotates for even cooking
- Viewing window
- No preheating required – just turn on and go!
- Adjustable temperature control settings
- Cooks up to 40% faster
- Up to 52% more energy efficient than a conventional oven
- Power indicator light
- Full enclosed
This Hamilton Beach Quesadilla and Pizza maker is our top recommended appliance for Best Quesadilla Makers.
This is an appliance that you can’t go wrong with. It’s durable, easy to use, easy to clean, and makes just about anything you can think of.
It may take a few times of trail and error in order to get the temperature settings right, but once you do, you’ll never go back to anything else.
Do yourself a favor and buy this kitchen appliance!
Santa Fe Quesadilla Maker
- Cooks tortillas in under 5 minutes
- Cooks 12 inch tortillas
- Nonstick cooking plates for easy clean up
- Includes drip tray
- Recipe book included
- Power and Ready to cook indicator lights
- Can be stored upright
- 1 year warranty!
This Sante Fe Quesadilla Maker is unique, not beause it does anything special, but because it does the basics really well.
It cooks monster size 12 inch quesadillas in under 5 minutes! That’s a big deal!
It also includes a recipe book and a 1 year warranty. The 1 year warranty is a big deal because there isn’t any other quesadilla maker that I’m aware of that has a warranty on its appliance.
Basically, you can’t go wrong with this pick!
El Paso Quesadilla Maker
- Nonstick coated plates
- Built in drip tray
- Indicator lights for on and off
- Ready light when it’s ready to cook
- Recipe book included
- Fits tortillas up to 8 inches
- Wrap around cord storage
The El Paso Quesadilla Maker is a solid appliance that will quickly and easily make your quesadillas and do so for a long time to come.
It doesn’t do anything fancy or unique, but it’ll make your quesadillas without any issues. It’s also affordable, which is always a plus!
My only real issue with it is that it’s on the smaller side, making only 8 inch quesadillas. Still, it’s a solid appliane if that doesn’t bother you.
Buying Guide – Best Quesadilla Makers
Quesadilla makers are just like any other appliance, there are special considerations when looking to buy one. We took at look at what some of those special considerations are and listed them below. Following this buyin gguide will help ensure that you get exactly what you want.
Size and Capacity
This is one of the most critical aspects of a quesadilla maker purchase to consider. It could make or break or decision.
How big should it be?
Most quesadilla makers range from 8 to 12 inches.
I usually advise people to go with a larger option. After all, you can fit 8 inch tortillas in a 10 inch quesadilla maker but you can’t fit 10 inch tortillas in an 8 inch one.
All of these quesadilla makers have plastic parts, that’s just a given nowadays. Still, some brands are known to last longer than others. That’s not just a coincidence, that’s because they’re built better.
Therefore, go with a brand that you know and that you feel comfortable with. And if they have a warranty, then even better!
Easy to Clean
Quesadillas are delicious, but they’re also pretty messy!
Whenever you’re heating up meat, cheese, and toppings, you’re bound to make a mess.
Cleaning up grease and food particles can be difficult, but features like nonstick plates and drip trays make it much easier.
Those are absolute must have features that you should look for in a quesadilla maker.
All of the quesadilla makers featured here have nonstick plates and drip trays, so shop away!
Budget is usually the top reason someone makes or doesn’t make a purchasing decision.
All of the quesadilla makers listed in this article are affordable, but there’s still a large price discrepancy from one to the other. They range from under $30 to well over $100.
A lower price doesn’t necessarily mean lower quality though. All of the appliances here, regardless of price, are high quality and durable.
Did you find one that you liked? These are all high-quality quesadilla makers. Which means it’s more about budget and features that you’re after. Our favorite is the Hamilton Beach Pizza and Quesadilla Maker. It’s affordable, high quality, and does much more than just cook quesadillas!